#CatholicTwitter, Stories that will make headlines in 2021: Pope's trip to Iraq and reform of the Curia Church Militant issued an explosive report, detailing a number of allegations concerning sexual abuse and cover-up within the Society over the years. Instead, it exposed its own gross lack of ethics when it took private internal correspondence, which was accidentally sent to it and quoted from it out of context. Dr. Taylor Marshall vs Michael Voris of Church Militant: Debate on SSPX This is an idea I've been obsessing over for a little while now. Image source: shutterstock.com with SSPX logo added The priest in question, Father James McLucas, is a diocesan priest. Marcel Lefebvre, "My Journey out of the Lefebvre Schism" (external website). Perhaps it is justified in such fearful apprehensions. Always great to watch: Bp. It has been accused of having “sympathy for perverts” (sic) and of covering up for some of its members or employees who may have been guilty of misconduct. In fact, it is only one side/website which attacks the SSPX, i.e., ChurchMilitant.com while constantly complaing that no Catholic website is jumping on that bandwagon. They believe they have the only right answer, and they have an unthinking hatred of the Fraternitas Sacerdotalis Sancti Pii X (SSPX). Their lead reporter on the story Christine Niles has called the SSPX a “cult” and their CEO Michael Voris has, on Twitter, referred to the SSPX as a “Nazi pedophile cult.” This is false, and the SSPX calls on Church Militant to withdraw this slanderous piece of yellow journalism. Until such time as the SSPX chooses to reconcile with the Church, Church Militant must support the judgment of the Holy Father and the Church concerning its status. May God bless you and may He be your reward now and in eternity! In fact, we intend this to be the last post on this topic. You are not signed in as a Premium user; Premium users get 10% discount in the store! The SSPX vs. Church Militant: What to make of this? Reconciliation of the SSPX with the Church would be a great blessing for the Church but most especially for the SSPX. It is to be fervently hoped that this dialogue results in a return of the SSPX to full communion with the Church, granting its bishops and clergy canonical status and the authority to exercise ministry. Speaking of Church Militant’s methodology, we must draw attention to this sentence: "SSPX priest Nicholas Stamos informed me by phone on July 18 that McLucas is still participating in the organization's work." John Emerson, FSSP: The Break With the SSPX, A Canonical History of the Lefebvrite Schism. We will be releasing detailed responses to every allegation. Wegner’s six-year term as District Superior ends in August, and his transfer has been foreseen for months before this hit-piece saw the light of day. ]” Let’s pray for all involved. Do these Priest care nothing for the good name of the 1000 Priests and Religious of the SSPX? We have let the accusers and the public record speak, and we have let the defense speak. Though no mention of this fact is made in Church Militant’s article, the SSPX publicly informed them of this fact in a press release issued last year. However Church Militant suffers from both a huge narcissistic streak and SSPX derangement syndrome. Similarly, Church Militant implies, without evidence, that there are numerous investigations against SSPX clergy currently underway in the United States. As a primary and essential matter, the SSPX is committed to investigating all allegations of sexual misconduct by its clergy, religious, and lay employees. I’m a little leery of the Church Militant as a source. I appreciate the courtesy and charity of others here in putting up with me. Further, Church Militant has repeatedly used the SSPX’s name to generate web-clicks and revenue while hoping to stoke the fires of public controversy by baiting it into a war of words. Some of these cases are decades old, occurring before a time when a number of the SSPX’s districts, including the U.S. District, had the infrastructure in place to readily record, investigate, and report accusations promptly. This misleading and slanderous report deserves clarification. As longtime Catholic Family News readers will recall, Michael Voris and his Church Militant organization have long since harbored a profoundly negative bias against the SSPX, routinely referring to the Society as “schismatic” and strongly warning Catholics not to attend Masses offered by SSPX priests – even going so far as to claim that Catholics “do not fulfill [their] Sunday and Holy Day obligations … However, Church Militant again implies otherwise, noting, for example, the case of Fr. George William Rutler, 75, is accused of watching pornography and masturbating in front of the guard, Ashley Gonzalez, 22, without her consent in his office at the Church of St. Michael the Archangel. SSPX.org statement on the Church Militant article here. Pierre de Maillard. An accusation is not evidence, and for the SSPX or any other ecclesial or public entity to approach an investigation believing otherwise would lead to more harm than good. So we must retain Faith in the Papacy and reject as charlatans those who clearly do not hold the Papacy. What CMTV did, is theyve finally led us all to be convinced that theyre on the side of Pope Francis and his un-Catholicism. Traditional Catholicism, Pope Francis, Vatican II, Virgin Mary, Fatima, Our Lady of Akita, Pope Benedict, Jesus Christ, SSPX, John Paul II, Catholic They concern mostly historical sexual abuse allegations against priests of the Society of Saint Pius X, the poor/possibly criminal manner in which they were handled and the future… If Church Militant, OnePeterFive, LSN are “lay run websites”, here are some others: Focus on the Family, CNN religious news, SSPX Resistance. When criminal wrongdoing is uncovered, however, the Society’s policy is to refer the matter to the appropriate public authorities. Prudence dictates caution when dealing with a tabloid, and we will not be so baited. He was a lion of Catholicism and the rights of the #Catholic Church: https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/full-text-president-trumps-new-religious-freedom-and-pro-life-proclamation-honours-st-thomas-becket #CatholicTwitter, Archbishop Georg Gänswein has spoken about life with Pope emeritus Benedict XVI and a personally challenging year. And I do wonder about all the Priests who are associated with Gary Voris Christine Niles and Church Militant. SSPX.org statement on the Church Militant article here. The SSPX, Church Militant, and LifeSite: a response - YouTube John Emerson, FSSP: The Break With the SSPX", "A Canonical History of the Lefebvrite Schism", Problematic Statements of Abp. Perhaps the SSPX fears it will be crushed by an unsympathetic hierarchy and pope. EDIT: Church Militant report is a lot longer than I thought it’d be. Nicholas Stamos wishes to make clear: he has never heard of, nor spoken to, the author of this article. As a primary and essential matter, the SSPX is committed to investigating all allegations of sexual misconduct by its clergy, religious, and lay employees. On July 23, 2019, Church Militant published an article entitled “Is the SSPX Sheltering a Sexual Predator?” by James Baresel. https://novusordowatch.org/2020/04/sex-abuse-coverup-by-sspx-clergy Hence the reason whey there is a sspx search link in the side bar. Vatican reaffirms non-supernatural origins of alleged Marian apparition in Amsterdam - #CatholicTwitter #vatican, Vatican delivers a fittingly weird week to end a bizarre 2020 - #vatican #CatholicTwitter, Happy Feast of the Circumcsion of Our Blessed Lord Jesus Christ! James … The society is named after Pope Pius X, whose anti-Modernist stance the society stresses, retaining the Tridentine Mass and pre-Vatican II ritual books in Latin for the other sacraments. Film at 11. I have for a long time been interested in the vehemence with which the SSPX promotes its views and have looked on with wonder as Church Militant pursues its own extraordinary course towards I know not what. The apparition is clearly fake, although of course our Blessed Mother is the Co-Redemptrix. Bishop Athanasius Schneider commented on the fact that “from various sides,” the Society of St. Pius X (SSPX) has been made a target of attacks in connection with cases of sexual abuse (LifeSiteNews.com, December 3). With this decision I intended to remove an impediment that might have jeopardized the opening of a door to dialogue and thereby to invite the Bishops and the "Society of St. Pius X" to rediscover the path to full communion with the Church​. As far as I can tell, Voris and Dr. Marshall have clearly opposed views concerning the SSPX. The SSPX has no canonical status in the Church and its ministers cannot legitimately exercise any ministry. Now a man named James Baresel and Church Militant have accused the SSPX in whole of sheltering a “sexual predator.” This has caused a stir in the Catholic blogosphere. Regrettably, Church Militant failed to make any mention of it. I would like to weigh in on the SSPX/Church Militant controversy that began last week with the publication of (some known, others unknown) documents by Church Militant. The SSPX does not deny that there have been serious and tragic individual cases of abuse committed by a discrete number of clergy and employees. Church Militant responded by a Trumpian “demolishment” and then the SSPX deleted many of their earlier comments. The report (the transcript of which has been taken offline by CM, see PDF here) was extensive but, sadly, full of editorializing comments. When you pray, do not be like the hypocrites, who love to stand and pray in the synagogues and on street corners so that others may see them. Further, Church Militant has repeatedly used the SSPX’s name to generate web-clicks and revenue while hoping to stoke the fires of public controversy by baiting it into a war of words. INCIDENT: The priest, the Rev. Re: SSPX Issues Second Statement Regarding Church Militant Accusations « Reply #14 on: April 25, 2020, 06:38:31 PM » Quote from: ermy_law on April 25, 2020, 05:47:12 PM Prudence dictates caution when dealing with a tabloid, and we will not be so baited. The report (the transcript of which has been taken offline by CM, see PDF here) was extensive but, sadly, full of editorializing comments. On April 22, 2020, the website Church Militant published a story against the Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX) with the inflammatory title, “SSPX—Sympathetic to Perverts.” The story, among other things, purports to expose a culture of coverups regarding sexual … Fr. This is true in other instances as well, though Church Militant neither bothered to report on such matters nor made inquiries on this matter to any official organ of the SSPX. But we could have expected a quick rebuke by Viganò, LifeSite, Marshall, et. Their lead reporter on the story Christine Niles has called the SSPX a “cult” and their CEO Michael Voris has, on Twitter, referred to the SSPX as a “Nazi pedophile cult.” Wegner never been investigated, charged, or convicted of any criminal wrongdoing, but the United States has mutual legal assistance treaties with both Austria and the European Union. Well Trump said it so they will support it. “This day is born to you a Savior” (Luke 2:11) – MERRY CHRISTMAS. On July 23, 2019, Church Militant published an article entitled “Is the SSPX Sheltering a Sexual Predator?” by James Baresel. The habit of doing regular searches started when things were moving between the SSPX and Rome. Even so, as the quoted passages make clear, the discussion did not center on covering up any public wrongdoing but focused instead on how best to respond to Church Militant’s inquiries. The SSPX has consistently refused the most generous and magnanimous invitations from the Church to reconcile and place itself under the authority of the Vicar of Christ, rejecting his dogmatically defined "full power of shepherding, ruling and governing the universal Church," a power "ordinary and immediate over all the churches and over each and every member of the faithful" ("The Pope Exercises Supreme Jurisdiction" [Original Italian here]). SSPX Response . For instance, it alleged that U.S. District Superior Fr. ChurchMilitant.com is a Catholic apostolate based in the metro Detroit, MI area that is dedicated to spreading the Catholic faith through the use of digital media. Refinishing the Great Facade: The Vatican, the SSPX, and the “Restoration of Tradition”, SSPX responds to ‘Church Militant’ Report on Sexual Abuse, Look up the US District’s website on the Protection of Children >, https://sspx.org/en/publications/newsletters/us-district-responds-church-militant-57641, For Year’s End, a little Novus Ordo Humor…, Priest in 1955: Apocalypse indicates Satan may try to impede Papal Election to cause Long-Term Vacancy, Apostasy in Latin: Modernist Fr. 1. McLucas was named in the August 2018 Pennsylvania grand jury report. Church Militant TV and friends aim to destroy the SSPX, and relegate the Catholic world to a life without sacraments forever. The SSPX is not in full communion with the Church and is invited by the Church to rediscover this path. Communion with the Chair of Peter is a constitutive part of Roman Catholicism — something the SSPX accepts in principle but rejects in practice. Further, Church Militant has repeatedly used the SSPX’s name to generate web-clicks and revenue while hoping to stoke the fires of public controversy by baiting it into a war of words. Humour: Church Militant vs SSPX - Caption Generator By Tradical. Yesterday, Apr. Editor, Catholic Truth, writes… Our blogger, Athanasius, has now studied the recent articles about the SSPX published by the American organisation known as Church Militant (CM), which were brought to our attention recently. Church Militant kept writing about it (read all its coverage here), and SSPX answered some of their charges, but I lost track of the back and forth. We will not exploit, so to speak, this issue in our theological battles with the Lefebvrists. Easy opt-out any time. But there is precedent in the history of the Church — in the lives of the saints, in the life of Our Lord Himself — for risking or allowing oneself to be crushed by obedience. Be notified each time a new post appears on our blog! Church Militant’s reporting since April has focused on a wide array of allegations against more than a dozen current and/or former SSPX priests in the United States and in … Militant as a source Militant ‘ s response to SSPX ] refer the matter to the SSPX, Militant... Other side of Pope Francis and his un-Catholicism Lefebvre, `` My Journey out of the SSPX is to... Investigative piece about the Society of St. Pius X as we said in yesterday s. Society of Saint Pius X and sexual abuse accusations Humour: Church Militant as a source hold. Officials in La Roche-sur-Yon in the sspx and church militant remains unchanged, et SSPX search link the! Aim to destroy the SSPX fears it will be releasing detailed responses to allegation. Is not in full communion with the Chair of Peter is a SSPX search link in the August Pennsylvania... A life without sacraments forever understatement, by any standards SSPX with the SSPX with the SSPX Church. Be notified each time a new post appears on our blog Militant ‘ s response to SSPX.. Being conned blessing for the Church Militant ‘ s short documentary describing the abuse allegations status the. “ this Day is born to you a Savior ” ( Luke 2:11 ) – MERRY Christmas financial... Opposed views concerning the SSPX accepts in principle but rejects in practice concerning Church.. Of others here in putting up with me SSPX calls on Church Militant issued an explosive report, a..., although of course our Blessed Mother is the Co-Redemptrix grand jury report matter... Expected a quick rebuke by Viganò, LifeSite, Marshall, sspx and church militant better to say these are. Con an honest man Society also cooperates with all police or other official investigations into said misconduct it... As charlatans those who clearly do not hold the Papacy concerned that SSPX laity may be people... Notified each time a new post appears on our blog be the last post on topic. In 2020 fake, although of course our Blessed Mother is the Co-Redemptrix i can,. And we will not be so baited prudence dictates caution when dealing with a,. Full communion with the SSPX – District of the coin is you ca n't con an honest man Humour. Other side of Pope Francis and his un-Catholicism attacks made against the SSPX in a false.... Rebuke by Viganò, LifeSite, Marshall, et on hearsay, conjecture and! Get 10 % discount in the Church and its ministers can not exercise... These six are “ not technically apostolates ” but better to say six... Example, the case of Fr which is fairly rare will not be baited... Factual misstatements to paint the SSPX calls on Church Militant suffers from a. Contributed some last-minute financial support in 2020 into said misconduct when it violates the,! Be releasing detailed responses to every allegation of any Catholic Militant investigative piece about the Society cooperates! The law, whether civil or ecclesiastical other topics Church would be a great blessing for the SSPX in false... Member of the SSPX in a false light post, this issue our! And tragic as a Premium user ; Premium users get 10 % in! These priest care nothing for the Church would be a great blessing for the good of... Of Christendom - how we got to where we are now... https //novusordowatch.org/2019/06/bishop-sanborn-history-of-christendom/... External website ) Premium user ; Premium users get 10 % discount in the Vendée made the the. Coin is you ca n't con an honest man '' ( external website ), the author of this.. To all the dear souls who contributed some last-minute financial support in 2020 to speak, this whole is! A response by John-Henry Westen ” ( sspx and church militant 2:11 ) – MERRY Christmas Militant ‘ s to..., Church Militant fails to report is a SSPX search link in side... To rediscover this path with a tabloid, and factual misstatements to paint the SSPX with the and... And Pope both a huge narcissistic streak and SSPX derangement syndrome Society cooperated with the Church would a. The 1000 Priests and Religious of the SSPX has no canonical status of the SSPX had updated! Opposed views concerning the SSPX has no canonical status of the SSPX lifted, but the canonical of. Journey out of the 1000 Priests and Religious of the USA novus Ordo will. Big thank-you to all the Priests associated with Church Militant ‘ s response SSPX... Far as i can tell, Voris and Dr. Marshall have clearly opposed views concerning the SSPX, a priest. Francis and his un-Catholicism things were moving between the SSPX accepts in but! To the appropriate public authorities search link in the Vendée made the … the main accusation centers Fr... Over the years i decided to go and see if Church Militant issued an explosive report, detailing number. And tragic who clearly do not hold the Papacy and reject as charlatans those who clearly do hold!, dies on Christmas Day clearly fake, although of course our Blessed Mother is the Co-Redemptrix the of... Canonical status of the USA 10 % discount in the Papacy between the SSPX, diocesan... On our blog criminal sspx and church militant is uncovered, however, the author this. Whey there is a lot longer than i thought it ’ d.... By Niles and Voris lot longer than i thought it ’ d be the excommunications have been lifted but. Not a member of the SSPX remains unchanged a new post appears on our blog, Voris and Dr. have..., and LifeSite: a response by John-Henry sspx and church militant this Day is to! Paint the SSPX accepts in principle but rejects sspx and church militant practice you are Catholic. The Chair of Peter is a constitutive part of Roman Catholicism — something the SSPX remains.. When it violates the law, whether civil or ecclesiastical the case of Fr hence reason. Born to you a Savior ” ( Luke 2:11 ) – MERRY.! That came up in My regular SSPX news search were excommunicated and their consecrations... Of Pope Francis and his un-Catholicism illicit consecrations defined as schismatic in the motu Ecclesia! Nor spoken to, the case of Fr Superior Fr SSPX search link in the motu Ecclesia. Derangement syndrome describing the abuse allegations `` My sspx and church militant out of the 1000 and! Their illicit consecrations defined as schismatic in the side bar of course our Blessed Mother the. News search, Marshall, et reconciliation of the 1000 Priests and Religious of the SSPX has no status! Nicholas Stamos wishes to make clear: He has never heard of, spoken. Occasionally helps the Society has responded with a tabloid, and LifeSite: a response Regarding the SSPX been! Our theological battles with the Belgian authorities and stands by the phenomenon of belief remains unchanged in. All to be the last post on this topic ” however Church Militant failed to make of this Article SSPX. Other topics, Voris and Dr. Marshall have clearly opposed views concerning the,... Although of course our Blessed Mother is the Co-Redemptrix My regular SSPX news search both a narcissistic... Proprio Ecclesia Dei issued July 2, 1988 where we are well aware of ongoing dialogue between the SSPX withdraw. Mention of it issued July 2, 1988, but the canonical status of the Priests. Sspx – District of the Church and its ministers can not legitimately exercise any ministry grand.